In his trenchant polemic against sociobiology and professor wilson, professor marshall sahlins remarks, for example, that the same genealogical and physical family relationships bear utterly different labels in the context of different social customs in different societies. The issue between sociobiology and social anthropology, he writes 1977, p. Marshall sahlins is one of the finest anthropologists of the postww ii period. The use and abuse of biology marshall david sahlins 1976 a criticism of. Marshall sahlins chapter 2 the divine kingship of the shilluk. Sociobiology, sahlins proclaims, contributes primarily to the final translation of natural selection into social exploitation. Wilson, the butt of his critique in this slim volume, is perhaps the most celebrated living naturalist and animal behaviorist. One of the most influential cultural anthropologists of the latter part of the twentieth century, marshall sahlins has written seminal works on economic anthropology, social and cultural theory, and the relation of culture and history. The split between the two cultures did not begin, as c. Waiting for foucault, still evols at university of. Being afterdinner entertainment by marshall sahlins for the fourth decennial conference of the association of social anthropologists of the commonwealth, oxford, 29 july 1993. Pdf the evolution of marshall sahlins researchgate.
Sociobiology, he claims, only bears a seeming relationship to external reality because our western capitalist culture has developed the particular brand of biology from which sociobiology. Interview with marshall sahlins sage journals sage publications. In culture in practice, marshall sahlins proves himself to be one of the most. Grey distinguished professor emeritus of anthropology at the university of chicago. The book opens with sahlins s early general studies of. Marshall sahlins has 28 books on goodreads with 6598 ratings.
Abstract marshall sahlins anthropologist, professor. In an attack on sociobiology, marshall sahlins 1976 treats it as a status quo ideology grown out of late capitalist society. More than a compilation, this book unfolds as an intellectual autobiography. The use and abuse of biology the university of michigan press.
Wilsons book by the same name in 1975 and its claim to finally unify the social sciences by annexing them into the truly scientific scheme of biological measurements and grounding, thereby dropping the purely phenomological notion of culture in favor of the actual core of humanthings. Economic anthropology and anthropological economics by. At the time of the 1976 anthropology meetings, marshal1 sahlins s book the use and abuse of biology was freshly in print. Pdf marshall sahlins is one of the great names of modern. Oct 01, 1979 marshall sahlins has suggested that the fate of sociobiology s attempt to incorporate the human sciences depends on the success of the theory of kin selection. Citation when quoting material from this collection, the preferred citation is. I was reminded of this story when i first read marshall sahlins wonderful, scholarly, and humane account of what kinship isand is not.
Professor sahlins was a fellow at the center for advanced study in behavioral sciences in 196364 and in 196768 he held a guggenheim fellowship. Evanspritchard, times literary supplement since its first publication over forty years ago marshall sahlins stone age economics has estab. Sahlins s reportage and reflections on the antiwar movement in 1964 and 1965 mark the intellectual development from earlier general studies of. Apr 16, 2014 stone age economics marshall sahlins ambitiously tackling the nature of economic life and how to study it comparatively, stone age economics includes six studies which reflect the authors ideas on revising traditional views of the huntergatherer and socalled primitive societies, revealing them to be the original affluent society.
In the old kongo kingdom, for example 9 marshall sahlins chapter 4 the strangerkingship of the mexica 223 marshall sahlins. At the time of the 1976 anthropology meetings, marshal1 sahlinss book the. Essays that span the career of a prominent anthropologist and address the fundamental questions of the field. If you deem that anthropology is neither a form of pompous navelgazing, nor an exercise in making preposterous generalizations out of sketchy personal experiences, this book is for you. Marshall sahlins 92 or representative of the god hocart 1933, 1936 1970, 1950 1968. Marshall sahlins books list of books by author marshall sahlins. What kinship is and is not, by marshall sahlins, chicago. Waiting for foucault, still, a pocketsized book by sahlins published in 2002 by prickly paradigm, now available for free online in pdf on the anthropology of levistrauss on the anthropology of modernity. Neoevolutionism is the movement for which this book, evolution and culture, is a primary source. Culture in practice collects the academic and political writings from the 1960s through the 1990s of anthropologist marshall sahlins. On violence, utopia, and the human condition 65 david graeber chapter 3 the atemporal dimensions of history. This book is subversive to so many of the fundamental assumptions of west.
Downloaded by university of california, san diego at 20. The use and abuse of biology meet your next favorite book. May 01, 1978 sahlins first characterizes a vulgar sociobiology, which holds, he claims, that there is an isomorphism between biological and social properties, so that human social organiza tion represents given human predispositions 1 976b34. More than a compilation, culture in practice unfolds as an intellectual autobiography. Reviewed by jeffrey tobin, rice university in anahulu, kirch and sahlins bring to. Marshall sahlins department of anthropology, university of chicago, chicago, illinois 60637. Eskimo hunting groups, social kinship, and the possibility. Sociobiology, the book, dealt almost exclusively with ant societies, but the final chapter broached the subject of human society. Lord jenkins, professor strathern, dear colleaguesand other colleagues.
The anthropology ojhistory in the kingdom ojhawaii. With impeccable scholarship, conceptual imagination, and wit, david graeber and marshall sahlins think anew, and within a broad comparative scope, an ancient and illustrious question. The new synthesis is available in our book collection an online access to it is set as public so you can get it instantly. The bone of contention, wilsons monumental sociobiology 1975 was the opening shot of a forty year to date attempt to create. Marshall sahlins american anthropologist britannica. By and large he does so in the first three quarters of the book, only to descend into inanity in the last quarter, which argues that sociobiology is an ideological defense of capitalism. An anthropological critique of sociobiology 1977 marvin harris sociobiology and biological reductionism 1979 slide 8 m. Aqui, o conceituado antropologo marshall sahlins dispara contra os principais conceitos e temas da virada do seculo xxi.
The marshall sahlins papers consist of research notes and data about the hawaiian makahiki festival and james cooks voyage to hawaii 17781779. Although a little dated inasmuch as he deals with sociobiology in the wake of e. A criticism of sociobiology by one of the worlds foremost anthropologists. Marshall sahlins is professor of anthropology at the university of michigan. Quite possibly sahlins assault on sociobiology contributed to it reinventing itself under other names hewlett 2001, the most prominent of which, at the present time, being evolutionary. Sociobiology and evolutionary psychology are related fields, both ofwhich claim that biology. University of chicago library guide to the marshall. Marshall sahlins, in full marshall david sahlins, born december 27, 1930, chicago, illinois, u.
Sahlins book is an extended brief for a simple and cogent argument. Culture in practice collects both the seminal and the more obscure academic and political writings of the anthropologist marshall sahlins from the 1960s through the 1990s. Sociobiology refers to a field of study in biology, a specific evolutionary theory about social behavior, or a statement about human nature. The book opens with sahlins s early general studies of culture. Marshall sahlins was born on december 27, 1930 in chicago, illinois. To oversimplify his argument sahlins and sociobiology 161. Sahlins, marshall, the original affluent society abridged, ch. Some of his theories have prompted lively debate in the anthropological community, to the point where a peer, gananath obeyesekere of princeton university, published a 1992 work that challenged sahlins s views on the fate of james. Sociobiology, the book, dealt almost exclusively with ant societies, but the final chapter.
Search for more articles by this author pdf add to favorites. The author of numerous books, sahlins is a fellow of the american academy of arts and sciences and a member of the national academy of sciences. The clear implication is that gods precede the kings who effectively replicate themwhich is not exactly the common social science tradition of cosmology as the reflex of sociology. Wilsons sociobiology in the anzericari anthropologist said that it clearly wins the prize as the worst book in biology for 1975. A criticism of sociobiology by one of the worlds forem. Sahlins, marshall, the original affluent society abridged. Harris reproductive success cannot be demonstrated or tested cultural materialism ecology offers simpler explanations without assuming rs slide 9. Sahlins s reportage and reflections on the antiwar movement in 1964 and 1965 mark the intellectual development from earlier general studies of culture, economy, and human nature to the more historical and globally aware works on indigenous peoples, especially. Marshall sahlins is a respected anthropologist whose specialty is the people and culture of the south pacific. Or, some triumphs of culture over despondency theory in culture and sustainable development in the pacific, edited by anthony hooper.
Yet when you come to examine it the original affluent society was none other than the hunters in which all the peoples material wants were easily satisfied. Marshall sahlins has resigned from the national academy of. Marshall sahlins is emeritus professor of anthropology at the university of chicago, and the author of stone age economics 1972 and the forthcoming the enchanted universe. Eskimo hunting groups, social kinship, and the possibility of. As an anthropologist he denies that there can be a valid argument. Adaptation and human behavior department of anthropology. Grey distinguished service professor emeritus of anthropology and of social sciences at the university of chicago. Dorigine russe, vous etes ne a chicago, berceau dune grande ecole d. The article that comes before the book summary has the same names in it as the collection, which is also named in the article. What is most striking about sahlins discussion is the evocative way in which he captures something immediately recognizable about kinship.
Sahlins first characterizes a vulgar sociobiology, which holds, he claims, that there is an isomorphism between biological and social properties, so that human social organiza tion represents given human predispositions 1 976b34. In an ironic way, human behavioral ecology owes marshall sahlins an intel. Chicagos anthropology department for decades, sahlins is also. The western illusion of human nature, marshall sahlins, 2008. The original political society university of chicago. Books by marshall sahlins author of stone age economics. Marshall sahlins books list of books by author marshall.
Emeritus professor marshall sahlins is a veteran of nature vs. Sociobiology, he claims, only bears a seeming relationship to external reality because our western capitalist culture has developed the particular brand of biology from which sociobiology evolved. A catalogue record for this book is available from the british library. It is a precious fact that an institutionalist kind of economics first appears in anthropology in direct relation to field research among exotic societies, that is to say, as a western experience of these societies. Marshall sahlins huntergatherers consume less energy per capita per year than any other group of human beings. Structure in the early history of the sand wich islands kingdom. Though his work is widely respected, a number of his theories placed him at the crux of heated.
377 1183 1582 1460 1840 1419 1752 372 980 1010 651 1260 1040 1237 805 1525 1317 1174 1345 1157 1593 382 1279 188 846 1663 545 1403